What can the Advertising Industry learn from the New York Yankees?

What the 2016 Yankees rebuild could teach an advertising industry that needs to change.

avatar

James Orsini

Aug 9, 2016, 3 min read

If you know me, in addition to family, the two things I really have a passion for are The New York Yankees and the business of advertising. As a fan, 2016 has been a trying time for the team I love, and as a 25 year advertising veteran, 2016 has been a trying time for the industry that I love so much as well.

After more winning seasons than I can count, and 27 Championship rings, the Yankees are simply not winning on the field. I see the same in the advertising industry. After decades as an industry of aspiration, the industry as we know it is losing ground and its voice. It is hard to watch two of my favorites just “not performing” in their collective space. Two “winners,” for as long as I can remember, on the “losing side” of the table in 2016.

After the all-star break this year the Yankees took stock of themselves. I’m happy to report that it wasn’t just me who noticed they were not winning. Like the equivalent of a doping scandal with steroids, the ANA's media findings was a wake-up call for the advertising industry. Something everyone knew was simply “part of how the game was being played.” One could say accepted cheating perhaps. At any rate, a time to take stock of the industry and a call for change.

It initially pained me to watch the dismantling of seemingly all that mattered for the Yankees in 2016. A killer 100mph+ bullpen (Miller and Chapman) and the top batting slugger on the team (Beltran). I quickly realized that what the Yankees were doing was taking what little value they had today and seeding it for greater value for tomorrow. In the trades that they made they got some of the top young prospects in all of baseball. Fans like myself went from being disappointed in a single season to being euphoric for next year and all the coming seasons. Management quickly went from goat to god. THEY RECOGNIZED THE NEED FOR CHANGE.

So why can’t the advertising industry see the same? Why must they continue to do what they have done year after year and expect a different result? 2016 CEO exits at Campbell Ewald, JWT, RAPP, Bailey Lauerman and most recently Saatchi demonstrate a further need for change. My hope is that the industry, like the Yankees, will find its way to again field a team of winners.

I have found that winning decisions often breed other winning decisions. For the Yankees that was Mark Teixeira’s emotional retirement. He recognized the team was trying to rebuild for the future by fielding young winners. He recognized he was no longer performing on the field. He willingly stepped aside to make room for change. He went out on top--head up high, shoulders back. Will some of the top leaders and players of the advertising industry step up (or down) and do the same?

And what about A-Rod? No longer performing on the field but still contracted for millions and obligated to be paid. A great solution for both the Yankees and A-Rod personally, to impart wisdom to others. In his new special adviser role, he will now coach, cultivate and impart greatness, share learned mistakes, how to do some things and how NOT to do others. Is there anyone at the top of the advertising industry who will do the same for our youth? The young talent in our industry is hungry for this impartation. I see it on a daily basis at our young agency VaynerMedia.

I find it so refreshing each and every day to be around fresh and new ideas, which challenge the status quo, and a young and entrepreneurial founder leading an eclectic group of individuals who look to industry disruptors for guidance. This group has such an appreciation for understanding and observing the past history…but no desire to live in it every day. I remain optimistic that both my New York Yankees and the advertising industry will find their way to winning once again.

avatar

James Orsini

stacklist.com/jamesorsini

A multi-hat operator with 40+ years across finance, advertising, and operations. Trained at KPMG and Goldman Sachs, then spent 11 years scaling VaynerX from $42M to nearly $350M in revenue alongside Gary Vaynerchuk.

avatar

James saved this to The James Orsini Blog, a stack of 24 cards

Built for AI agentsACO · 963 tokens

Summary

The advertising industry can learn from the New York Yankees' 2016 strategy of dismantling underperforming assets to invest in young talent and future success. Like the Yankees' trades and leadership transitions, the advertising industry must embrace change, mentor emerging talent, and move away from outdated practices to regain its competitive edge.

Tags

advertising · new-york-yankees · industry-change · leadership · organizational-transformation · sports-business-analogy · talent-development

Key entities

New York Yankees (organization, 0.99) · VaynerMedia (organization, 0.95) · ANA (organization, 0.85) · Mark Teixeira (person, 0.9) · A-Rod (person, 0.9) · Miller (person, 0.75) · Chapman (person, 0.75) · Beltran (person, 0.85) · Campbell Ewald (organization, 0.8) · JWT (organization, 0.8) · RAPP (organization, 0.8) · Bailey Lauerman (organization, 0.8) · Saatchi (organization, 0.8) · New York (location, 0.95) · organizational-transformation (concept, 0.85)

Classification

analysis · language en · status final

Provenance

claude-haiku-4-5 via @stacklist/be@0.1.0, confidence 0.85, 28 Oct 2026