My Observations from Inside the Boardroom
Lessons from public company, university and nonprofit boardrooms, prompted by the Business Roundtable’s shift to stakeholders.
James Orsini
Aug 28, 2019, 3 min read
The recent announcement by The Business Roundtable to redefine their mission around Stakeholder CEOs has me reflecting on my time spent in publicly traded boardrooms, Higher Education boardrooms, non- for- profit boardrooms and client boardrooms. This recent attempt to embrace and serve stakeholders as well as shareholders had me dig deeper into understanding the pivot. Stakeholders here are defined as customers, employees, suppliers and communities as well as the shareholders who own the company.
As an operational leader, I can tell you a well-run and harmonious boardroom is vitally important to the success of every organization. Integrity matters, and this tone is set from the top. Drop one rotten apple into a bushel of nice shiny good apples and the entire bushel will become rotten. Conversely, one good apple dropped into a bushel of bad apples will not restore the group. As my boss Gary Vaynerchuk often says, “Doing the right thing is always the right thing”; this holds true for the boardroom. Now that right thing has been extended beyond simply shareholders who own the stock, but also the stakeholders that matter to that organization. A big mantle for a now even broader remit.
Board size matters, too small is ineffective and too big, there’s too many and the room becomes unruly. Order matters and the Chairman or Lead Director plays a vital role here. At a recent client presentation to a boardroom of no less than two dozen directors, I spent 60% of my time (as a presenter) restoring order in the room. I could not even tell you who the Chairman or Lead Director of this publicly traded Pharma company was. Bringing smart and passionate people back to focus on the agenda we were all there to accomplish is such an important factor for success. There is nothing more valuable than time. I have worked hard to value my own and others and have little tolerance for folks who waste it.
Make sure the room has several truly “independent” directors. Independent defined here as not influenced or controlled by others in matters of opinion, conduct, etc. The boardroom should have some reflection of your consumer or community. If you are there to now serve stakeholders beyond just shareholders, how can it not? In higher education having a young alumnus on the board proved invaluable for many topics of discussion.
The audit committee is important and should be taken very seriously. Thoughtful care should be given to who is appointed to serve here, and their recommendations made back to the overall board should not be taken lightly. Sarbanes Oxley is well intended, auditors should be periodically rotated, and Chief Compliance Officers are no longer a luxury, but a must have, in most larger organizations.
Lastly, in the world of emerging technology, not every good entrepreneur or founder makes for a good publicly traded company CEO. These are simply different skill sets. There is no substitute for wisdom and experience regardless of how smart one is. CEOs need mentors too. Iron sharpens iron in the boardroom. When I was a CEO, I relied heavily on several board members who had experience with the SEC and public markets to help guide me.
This recent stakeholder value proposition has made me want to toss my hat back in the ring and serve on the right publicly traded board. I will use my recent observations from a rapidly growing digital company predicated on empathy for his employees, serving its clients with excellence and sharing knowledge with its communities, all while walking the walk of doing the right thing is always the right thing to help those inside the boardroom for 2020 and beyond.